Navigating Insolvency as a Self-Employed Individual: Key Considerations

by Shannon Jackson, CIRP, LIT
November 19, 2024

For self-employed individuals, managing finances can come with unique challenges. Running a business often means dealing with fluctuating income, difficulty accessing traditional credit, and the need to separate personal and business finances. When financial struggles arise, the path to debt relief can feel complex. The Canadian Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Professionals (CAIRP) offers resources to help Licensed Insolvency Trustees (LITs) guide self-employed individuals through tailored insolvency solutions, such as consumer proposals and bankruptcy, which can provide relief and enable a fresh start.

Here’s an in-depth look at the key considerations for self-employed individuals facing insolvency and how Licensed Insolvency Trustees (LITs) can help navigate the process.

Key Financial Challenges for Self-Employed Individuals

Self-employed individuals, from freelancers to small business owners, often face financial difficulties distinct from those experienced by salaried employees. Some of these challenges include:

1. Fluctuating Income

Self-employment can mean an unpredictable cash flow, with earnings varying significantly month-to-month. This income volatility can make it challenging to budget, pay down debts consistently, and meet financial obligations.

2. Limited Access to Credit

Traditional lenders often view self-employed individuals as higher risk due to their unpredictable income, making it difficult to access loans or lines of credit. This can lead to reliance on high-interest credit options, such as credit cards or alternative lenders, which can quickly become unmanageable.

3. Separation of Personal and Business Finances

Many self-employed individuals struggle to maintain a clear distinction between personal and business finances. This intertwining can make it harder to assess the financial health of the business and manage tax obligations accurately, especially when filing additional tax returns and financial statements for Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).

With these unique challenges, self-employed individuals may find themselves more vulnerable to financial distress, especially when unexpected expenses arise or revenue drops. Insolvency may become a necessary consideration to regain financial control and restructure debt.

In this video, LIT Shannon Jackson provides guidance for self-employed individuals facing insolvency. Watch for key considerations, and read on for additional strategies.

 

 

Insolvency Options for Self-Employed Individuals

Licensed Insolvency Trustees offer options to help self-employed individuals address their debt issues and, when possible, continue operating their businesses. The primary options include consumer proposals and bankruptcy, both of which have specific applications for self-employed people.

1. Consumer Proposals

A consumer proposal is a formal arrangement with creditors that allows individuals to settle their unsecured debt for less than the total owed. This option is particularly advantageous for self-employed individuals who wish to keep their business assets and continue operations. Since self-employed individuals are often sole proprietors, their personal and business liabilities are linked. As a result, a consumer proposal can address both types of debt, providing a way to handle personal and business-related obligations together.

By filing a consumer proposal, a debtor can:

  • Negotiate a Reduced Debt: Many consumer proposals result in paying back a portion of the debt rather than the full amount.

  • Keep Assets: Unlike bankruptcy, a consumer proposal allows debtors to retain their assets, such as business tools or equipment, which are essential for continuing their work.

  • Stop Creditor Actions: Once a consumer proposal is filed, creditors are legally bound by its terms and must halt collection actions, such as wage garnishments or lawsuits.

Many self-employed individuals find that a consumer proposal provides the necessary relief from their debt load, offers a manageable cash flow, and enables them to remain on good terms with CRA. Licensed Insolvency Trustees are skilled in structuring consumer proposals that meet both the business and personal needs of self-employed individuals, helping them achieve a sustainable balance between their income and debt repayments.

2. Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy is another option for individuals with unmanageable debt, though it comes with certain implications for self-employed individuals. While bankruptcy may not be the first choice for those wishing to continue operating a business, it remains a viable option for those with limited income and assets.

Key points of bankruptcy for self-employed individuals include:

  • Evaluation of Assets: During bankruptcy, an LIT will evaluate both personal and business assets to determine their value. In many provinces, legislation allows debtors to retain certain “tools of the trade,” enabling them to continue earning a livelihood.

  • Impact on Business Operations: Declaring bankruptcy does not necessarily mean closing the business. Many self-employed individuals can still operate their business; however, they may face limitations in accessing new credit, especially with suppliers.

  • Debt Relief: Bankruptcy can provide significant debt relief by discharging eligible debts. However, it may have long-term effects on creditworthiness and future business opportunities.

Self-employed individuals should discuss both options with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to determine the best route based on their financial situation and long-term goals.

Special Considerations for Self-Employed Insolvency

When filing for insolvency, self-employed individuals must address specific factors related to their business operations and financial documentation. Here are some considerations to keep in mind:

1. Maintaining Accurate Financial Records

Proper documentation is essential for self-employed individuals going through insolvency. This includes keeping detailed financial statements, tax returns, notices of assessment, and records of any outstanding debts. Accurate documentation helps the LIT assess the financial situation more effectively and tailor a debt solution that aligns with the debtor’s goals.

2. Impact on Future Business Opportunities

Filing for insolvency can affect creditworthiness and future access to capital. Self-employed individuals should be aware that bankruptcy or a consumer proposal may make it more challenging to secure business financing or supplier credit in the future. An LIT can help individuals understand these implications and develop strategies for rebuilding credit over time.

3. Setting Clear Business Goals

For self-employed individuals, business and personal finances are often intertwined. Before pursuing insolvency, individuals should have clear goals for their business, whether they intend to continue operations, downsize, or wind down the business entirely. Licensed Insolvency Trustees can assist in evaluating the viability of the business and exploring options that align with the individual’s objectives.

By understanding these considerations, self-employed individuals can make informed decisions about insolvency and develop a plan that supports their personal and business aspirations.

Working with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee: The Path to Financial Relief

Navigating insolvency as a self-employed person requires professional guidance, and Licensed Insolvency Trustees play an invaluable role in this process. LITs offer a free initial consultation, providing individuals with a comprehensive assessment of their financial situation and a clear explanation of available options.

During the consultation, self-employed individuals can expect the following:

  1. Personalized Assessment: LITs conduct a thorough review of the debtor’s financial records, including income, expenses, assets, and debts. This personalized assessment allows the LIT to recommend an appropriate solution tailored to the debtor’s circumstances.
  2. Explanation of Insolvency Options: The LIT will outline the benefits and drawbacks of both consumer proposals and bankruptcy, explaining how each option applies to self-employed individuals. They will address how assets, liabilities, and cash flow may be affected, as well as the impact on future credit.
  3. Assistance with Documentation: For self-employed individuals, gathering financial documentation can be a challenge. LITs provide guidance on the specific documents needed for filing insolvency, making the process smoother and more efficient.
  4. Strategic Planning for Business Continuity: Licensed Insolvency Trustees help individuals evaluate the viability of their business and explore strategies for continuing operations. Whether the goal is to maintain the business or wind it down, an LIT can assist in creating a debt solution that supports the debtor’s financial and career goals.

Moving Forward with Financial Stability

Facing insolvency as a self-employed individual can be a daunting experience, but it doesn’t have to signal the end of business operations or financial stability. Licensed Insolvency Trustees offer tailored solutions, including consumer proposals and bankruptcy options, that can help individuals regain control of their finances while allowing them to continue their work.

Whether it’s restructuring debt, creating a manageable repayment plan, or protecting essential business assets, LITs provide the guidance and expertise needed to make informed decisions. Self-employed individuals can achieve peace of mind knowing that there are paths to debt relief that honor their unique needs and business aspirations.

If you’re a self-employed individual struggling with unmanageable debt, consider reaching out to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee today. With professional assistance, you can explore your options, protect your assets, and focus on rebuilding your financial future. Use CAIRP’s “Find a CIRP LIT” tool to locate a qualified trustee near you, and take the first step toward achieving financial freedom.